Showing posts with label ecological release. Show all posts
Showing posts with label ecological release. Show all posts

Saturday, January 30, 2010

Ecological Opportunity and White Sands






Simone here.

Before I start, I want to provide some links to my website and my supervisors' websites.


Today I'm going to write about Ecological Opportunity and how this concept relates to the three lizard colonists of White Sands. This topic has been the focus of my first field season so forgive me if I go on too long!

Let's start with a definition. I'm going to pull my definition from all over the place... and primarily from my head.

An ecological opportunity is basically anything that leads to the increased niche breadth of a species. For example, the evolution of a key innovation (that allows access to a new adaptive zone), the colonization of a novel environment, the extinction of antagonists (competitors, predators)... or some combination of the above. I should note that originally ecological opportunity was defined mostly in the context of release from competition pressures. And really, we can think of all of the above as relating to this in some context. A population might colonize a new environment without competitors, in the case of White Sands, for example.

I think this is a good opportunity (ha) to talk about my own research a bit. I am looking at White Sands as a potential setting for ecological release for the three species of lizard colonists. During my last field season I surveyed inside and outside White Sands to see if there was a significant reduction in the number of potential predators and competitors in the latter. Furthermore, I began to look for evidence of ecological release in one of the three colonist species: Sceloporus undulatus (see picture of male from White Sands above). I looked at whether sceloporus use of their microhabitat (perches) was more variable in White Sands compared to their use in ancestral dark populations.

My results have so far indicated that
1. the abundance of the total lizard population in White Sands is comparable to that in ancestral dark soils. This is cool because the former only has three species, whereas the latter has several- up to 10 or more. We use the term 'density compensation' to describe this increase in population size.
2. bird abundance also was higher outside White Sands- although I haven't yet classified this birds as potential competitors or predators (or neither)... and it will be interesting to see how this influences my results.
3. my results from quantifying sceloporus perches were provocative. Both sceloporus in dark soils and White Sands use their perches selectively... that is, not proportional to their availabilities in the habitats. However, White Sands lizards used a greater variety of their available* perches than did dark soils lizards. In other words, the DIVERSITY of perch use by White Sands sceloporus was higher than that of dark soils sceloporus.... cool!
This could suggest that there is some sort of alleviation from selective pressures in White Sands sceloporus. Perhaps the absence of interspecific competitors in White Sands allows the sceloporus there to expand their perch use. Perhaps research into diet and food resource use will demonstrate a similar trend... but that is for another field season.



*I say and mean available. This is an important point because, as Schluter says, resource heterogeneity may exist; that is, the 'depauperate communities' that are colonized not only have fewer competitors, but also may contain fewer available resources. This is likely the case in White Sands, where perches are far scarcer than in surrounding dark soils.


Saturday, January 16, 2010

ADAPTIVE RADIATION- how the heck does this relate to White Sands lizards.


This image of White Sands, NM is from google maps.

Simone- signing on.

So Schluter focused a lot on the definitions of Adaptive Radiation and other concepts surrounding the term. Let's see what he says.
On the first few pages of chapter 3, Schluter outlines the four main features of an adaptive radiation. Here they are in abbreviated form:
1. common ancestry of component species
2. phenotype-environment correlation
3. trait utility (certain traits have a fitness advantage in respective environments)
4. rapid speciation.

We're not by any means suggesting that adaptive radiation has or will occur in White Sands lizards. But the parallel colonization by the three lineages is interesting in this context because many believe (Lister, Wilson, Simpson etc.) that this invasion of open and new territory is a key component of the initial stages of an AR. We'll talk about this concept of Ecological Release in more detail later.

Why don't we think that AR wouldn't occur in White Sands lizards?
We discussed this a little when Kayla and I met last time. Well first of all, when we look at adaptive radiations on islands... well, see, that's the thing. Adaptive radiations are on islandS! Not just one! Hawaiian silverswords, fruitflies and honey creepers, Galapagos finches and Caribbean anoles- they all inhabit archipelagos. Even if we consider White Sands as a relatively isolated and recently formed island... it is just one. Even the subdivision of interdune areas by high uninhabitable dunes is only ever temporary. The dunes are always moving, changing the configuration of habitable, vegetated space. One might imagine that the populations of lizards in White Sands are quite dynamic. And an adaptive radiation in the face of that kind of gene flow? I think not!

But some adaptive radiations seem to be born from multiple colonizations of the same lineage in one 'island' (stickleback, cichlids, anoles...):

Could we get an adaptive radiation of lizards in White Sands due to several invasions from surrounding dark soils habitats?
What do population genetics tell us about the structure of populations in White Sands?
Would this be more common in certain lizard species? (i.e. Holbrookia populations outside White Sands are far more disjunct and they have no continuous distribution over the ecotone from dark soils to White Sands).
Is there enough distinctive niche space for lizards in White Sands? Or is niche space indeterminate, with diversity begetting diversity (Whittaker)?

Over to you, Kayla!